When you speak, I guarantee you will be heard
Zacarese & Zalewski P.C.
What Happens in a Neglect Case in Suffolk County, NY
Call now: 516-660-4354
"He didn't just win my case. He gave me back my future, my peace of mind, and my ability to breathe again."
From the very first conversation, he changed everything. He didn't just see a case, he saw me, and treated me like family. His knowledge of the law was unmatched, but what truly set him apart was his humanity. If you are looking for a lawyer, stop searching right now.
A neglect case in Suffolk County Family Court can feel like the ground is disappearing under your feet. One day you're living your life, and the next you're facing a court petition, a caseworker in your home, and the very real possibility of losing time with your children. It moves fast, and if you don't know what's coming, you can fall behind before you even get started.
What's at stake in these cases is not paperwork or legal technicalities. It's your children. It's your family. It's your right to be a parent. The court has enormous power in neglect proceedings, and the agency on the other side of the case has investigators, attorneys, and resources. You need someone in your corner who knows how to fight back.
Steven Zalewski has spent 40 years handling Family Court cases right here in Suffolk County. He has stood in the courtrooms at Central Islip and Riverhead through every stage of neglect proceedings, from the first emergency hearing to the final disposition. He knows how these cases work, how the agencies operate, and what it takes to protect your parental rights when everything feels like it's falling apart.
What Is Child Neglect Under New York Law?
Neglect in New York is defined under Article 10 of the Family Court Act. A child is considered neglected when a parent or guardian fails to provide adequate food, clothing, shelter, education, supervision, or medical care, and that failure causes or puts the child at risk of harm.
Some common examples of what CPS may allege as neglect include:
- Leaving a young child without supervision
- Failing to seek medical treatment for a sick or injured child
- Exposing a child to domestic violence in the home
- Substance abuse that impairs a parent's ability to care for a child
- Unsafe or unsanitary living conditions
It is important to understand that neglect cases in Family Court are civil, not criminal. You are not being charged with a crime. But do not let that give you a false sense of security. A neglect finding can result in the removal of your children, court-ordered services, supervised visitation, and in serious cases, proceedings to terminate your parental rights. The stakes are just as real.
How a Neglect Case Starts in Suffolk County
The CPS Investigation
Most neglect cases begin with a report made to the New York State Central Register or directly to Suffolk County Child Protective Services. Anyone can make a report, and certain professionals such as teachers, doctors, and social workers are required by law to report suspected neglect.
Once a report is received, CPS assigns a caseworker to investigate. That caseworker may show up at your home, contact your child's school, speak with neighbors or family members, and review medical or school records.
When It Goes to Court
Not every CPS investigation results in a court case. If CPS determines that a child is in immediate danger, they can seek an emergency removal order without advance notice to the parent. In less urgent situations, CPS may file a neglect petition in Suffolk County Family Court, and the process begins with a court appearance.
Understanding the difference between a voluntary case plan offered by CPS and a formal court petition matters. Agreeing to services informally is not the same as having a petition filed against you, but either situation can affect your case going forward.
The First Court Date: What to Expect
The first appearance in a neglect case is called the initial appearance or arraignment on the petition. This happens in Suffolk County Family Court, either at the Central Islip courthouse or in Riverhead.
At this first court date:
- The petition is formally presented and you will enter a response
- The judge may issue temporary orders, including supervision conditions or a temporary removal order if one has not already been issued
- An Attorney for the Child (AFC), sometimes called a law guardian, will be appointed to represent your child's interests
- If you do not have an attorney, you may be assigned one or given the opportunity to retain one
This first date sets the tone for the entire case. Going in without an attorney is one of the biggest mistakes a parent can make. Temporary orders issued at the first appearance can have lasting consequences, and you want someone there who can push back from day one.
Temporary Removal and Emergency Hearings
What Temporary Removal Means
If CPS believes a child is in immediate danger, they can seek an order to remove that child from the home before a full hearing takes place. This can happen fast, sometimes before you even know a petition has been filed.
The 1028 Hearing
Under Section 1028 of the Family Court Act, a parent has the right to request a hearing to have a removed child returned home. This hearing must be held within three court days of the request. At the 1028 hearing, the court looks at whether returning the child would create an imminent risk to the child's life or health.
This is one of the most important early battles in a neglect case. The burden is on the agency to show why the child should not come home. A strong presentation at a 1028 hearing, with the right evidence and the right attorney, can result in your child being returned while the case continues.
The Discovery and Pre-Trial Process
Before the case goes to a fact-finding hearing, both sides exchange evidence. In a neglect case, that evidence can include:
- CPS investigation records and caseworker notes
- Medical records and reports
- School attendance and performance records
- Prior CPS history
- Police reports or prior Family Court orders
Pre-trial conferences give the parties an opportunity to discuss the case, narrow the issues, and sometimes resolve matters without a full hearing. But not every case settles, and preparation for trial has to begin well before you walk into the courtroom. Showing up to fact-finding unprepared is not a strategy. It's a risk you cannot afford to take.
The Fact-Finding Hearing: The Trial
How Fact-Finding Works
The fact-finding hearing is the trial in a neglect case. This is where ACS or Suffolk County DSS presents its evidence and tries to prove that neglect occurred. You, through your attorney, have the right to challenge that evidence, cross-examine witnesses, and present your own case.
The burden of proof in a neglect case is preponderance of the evidence. That means the agency has to show that neglect is more likely true than not. It is a lower standard than a criminal case, but that does not mean the agency always wins. Evidence can be challenged, caseworkers can be cross-examined, and findings can be disputed.
Why a Real Trial Lawyer Matters
Cross-examining a CPS caseworker is not something every family law attorney is prepared to do well. It requires courtroom skill, knowledge of the evidence rules that apply in Family Court, and experience reading how a particular judge handles these cases. Steve Zalewski is a trial lawyer. He does not hand cases off or avoid the courtroom. If your case goes to fact-finding, he will be there fighting for you.
If the court does not find that neglect has been proven, the case is dismissed. If neglect is found, the case moves to the dispositional phase.
The Dispositional Hearing: What Comes After a Finding
A dispositional hearing follows a neglect finding and determines what happens next for your family. This is where the court decides what outcome is appropriate based on the child's best interests.
Possible dispositional outcomes include:
- Supervision: You keep your children, but the family is supervised by DSS for a period of time
- ACD (Adjournment in Contemplation of Dismissal): The case is adjourned and may be dismissed if you comply with certain conditions
- Mandatory services: Parenting classes, counseling, substance abuse treatment, or other programs
- Placement: The child is placed outside the home, either with a relative or in foster care
The dispositional hearing is not just a formality after a finding. It is your opportunity to present evidence about who you are as a parent, what you have done to address any issues, and why your family should stay together. Steve prepares clients for this phase just as seriously as he prepares for fact-finding.
If You Are Facing a Neglect Case in Suffolk County, Do Not Wait
A neglect case does not slow down while you figure out your next move. The agency has already started building its case. Court dates get scheduled fast, temporary orders go into effect, and the longer you wait to get an attorney involved, the harder it becomes to get ahead of what is happening.
Steve Zalewski has been doing exactly that for clients across Suffolk County for decades. He knows the courtrooms. He knows the law. And he knows what it takes to fight for a family when the stakes could not be higher.
If you or someone you love is facing a neglect proceeding in Suffolk County, call Steve directly. He picks up.
📧 steve@zandzfamilylawyers.com
📍 1601 Veterans Memorial Highway, Suite 500, Islandia, NY 11749
i guarantee you will be heard
Ready to Take the Next Step?
At Zacarese & Zalewski P.C., when something isn’t right, say something—and we’ll do something about it with you.
Our flat-fee structure is clear: one flat fee for pre-trial work, and a trial fee only if your case goes to trial or a hearing. Call now and a professional will return your call quickly; if we miss you, we'll call back the same day.
